How to vet a crypto KOL on X before you pay for a promo
Follower counts are cheap to fake. Four checks that show who actually reads a KOL, and the red flags that mean you should walk away.
Check four things before you pay: who follows the account, whether its followers are real, how it gained them, and who replies to its posts. It takes about ten minutes an account, and most of the accounts you should not pay fail on the first two.
The follower count is not one of the four. Followers are cheap to buy, and so are likes, reposts and views. A KOL with 80,000 followers and a few hundred real readers will quote you the same rate as one with 20,000 who all read every post.
1. Who follows them
Open futurepost.ai/profile/handle for the account. The header is free for any account and shows its smart score, its rank and how many smart followers it has: the core accounts of crypto X, the funds, founders and builders who follow each other.
Compare the follower count with the tier. An account with 80,000 followers in Emerging, the lowest tier, has a crowd that nobody in the industry follows along with. An account with 15,000 followers in Expert or above is followed by people your project wants to reach.
On Pro, the Followers tab answers the next questions:
- What kinds of smart account follow it. Funds and founders following a KOL is a different audience from other callers following them.
- Followed early by. Smart accounts that followed before the account was big. Insiders finding someone early is hard to fake.
- New smart followers week by week. A KOL who is gaining standing keeps adding them. One who peaked a cycle ago has stopped.
2. Whether the audience is real
The Audience tab sorts every follower into one of five groups: real and active, real but not yet seen, inactive, low value, and bots and scams. Audience quality lists the checks behind each one.
Divide the fee by the real, active followers, not by the follower count. A $2,000 post to 50,000 followers sounds like 4 cents a reader. If 9,000 of them are real and active, it is 22 cents, and the account with 20,000 followers and 12,000 active ones is the better buy at the same price.
Three more things on the same tab:
- Where the followers are. If your launch is for a Korean or Turkish market and the audience is somewhere else, the reach is not reach for you.
- What kinds of account they are. A DeFi protocol wants builders and funds in the audience, not only other callers.
- The communities they are in. For an NFT mint, the collections the followers hold say more about whether they will mint than anything the KOL tells you.
3. How they grew
Real audiences grow in curves: a viral thread, a busy week, a slow month. Bought followers arrive in steps, thousands in a day and then nothing, and they leave in steps too when X clears out fake accounts.
The Growth tab shows followers over time and how many followed and unfollowed each day. Follower history is kept for accounts on a Watchlist, which are read every day, so add your candidates as soon as they are on the shortlist. Two weeks of daily reads before you sign tells you a lot, and a few days still shows whether the count moves like people or like a purchase.
Names it has had
A profile lists the names the account has had. A KOL handle that started as a giveaway page, a meme account or a different person is an account somebody bought for its followers, and the followers came for whatever it was before.
4. Who engages with their posts
The Posts tab shows likes a post by week, the best posts, and who engages with them. Open the top posts and read the replies.
- Good: replies that argue, ask questions or add something, from accounts with real profiles.
- Bad: rows of “LFG”, “bullish” and rocket emoji, posted within a minute of each other, from accounts with default pictures and a long number in the handle. That is an engagement group or a bought package.
- Bad: views in the hundreds of thousands and a few dozen replies. Views are the easiest number on X to inflate.
Then find their last paid posts. Search from:handle (ad OR sponsored OR partner) on X, and look at how the replies to those compare with the replies to their own posts. A promo that gets nothing but the usual engagement group is what you are about to buy.
Make sure you are talking to them
KOL imposters are common: an account with the same picture and a handle one letter off, offering a promo at a discount and asking for payment up front. Agree terms from the real account, or confirm the DM from a post on it.
The free Futurepost extension puts a warning next to accounts confirmed as imposters or scams, on their profile, in the timeline, in follower lists and on hover cards.
Compare the shortlist
Compare puts up to four accounts side by side: followers, smart score, rank, smart followers, the smart share of their followers and account age. It works on any plan. Put the fee for each next to it and the cheapest reach is usually obvious.
Red flags, in short
- A big follower count in a low tier.
- Most followers inactive, low value or bots.
- Followers arriving in jumps of thousands.
- A past life under another name.
- Replies that all say the same thing in the same minute.
- Payment asked up front from an account you have not checked.
One flag is a question to ask them. Three is a pass.